Grilled Pimento Cheese

9810425335 a2a54d92f5 z Grilled Pimento Cheese

Earlier this year, I was having dinner with a friend when the topic of conversation turned to food. {This is not unusual, seeing as how most of our conversations end up being about food.} I was saying how my mother and I had just recently discovered the glory that is the grilled pimento cheese sandwich – made with my great-grandmother’s homemade pimento cheese recipe, of course. At this point my friend looked at me and said, “Wait a minute. You can make pimento cheese? I thought it only came from a jar.”

That statement took a minute to sink in. Pimento cheese out of a jar? After a bit of research {nerd alert}, I realized that she was referring to this. Friends, this may be a controversial statement, but that is not real pimento cheese.

Real pimento cheese is a Southern staple, and there are about as many recipe variations as there are opinionated Southern grandmothers, but – in general – it is a spread made up of sharp cheddar cheese, chopped pimentos, and mayo. Some recipes, such as my great-grandmother’s, may use additional ingredients like Worcestershire sauce, but those first three components are fairly consistent. Of course, there are a few people who use cream cheese in their pimento cheese, but I’m fairly certain that this idea would make my great-grandmother turn in her grave, so I personally stick to the basics.

I grew up eating pimento cheese sandwiches – literally, just pimento cheese and some slices of fresh tomato between two slices of bread – but for some reason it never occurred to my family to turn our pimento cheese into grilled cheese until recently.


I am so glad to have seen the light. Grill all the cheese!

Grilled Pimento Cheese
Yield: Makes enough pimento cheese for a least 4 sandwiches
  • 2 cups grated sharp cheddar cheese
  • ½ cup mayonnaise
  • 2-3 tablespoons chopped jarred pimentos
  • ½-1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
  • Slices of your favorite crusty bread
  • Butter
  1. Make the pimento cheese: In a bowl, stir together the cheese, mayonnaise, pimentos, and Worcestershire sauce until combined. Start by adding ½ teaspoon of Worcestershire sauce, and increase to up to 1 teaspoon as desired.
  2. Heat a skillet over medium heat. Spread a few tablespoons of the pimento cheese spread on a slice of bread. Top with a second slice, spread the top of the sandwich with butter, and place in the heated skillet, butter-side down. Spread butter on what is now the top slice of bread, and cook until the sandwich is golden brown on both sides, flipping halfway, for a total of 3-4 minutes. Cut in half and serve with your favorite tomato soup.


  1. Yesss! Here’s a funny story. Daddy told me awhile ago that he never did like pimento cheese (before he had Ma-Ma’s), because all he knew about was said jarred stuff. Bless his heart. I’m glad that he’s seen the light on many culinary glories. And, it’s thanks to Christina and her Instagram post from her honeymoon that made me see the light. And that light is grilled pimento cheese. :)

  2. Bless both of your hearts! Did you know that eating pimento cheese makes you pretty? Oh yes!

  3. Ooooooh lookat you! I’ve never had pimento cheese and am pretty sure, due to my complete wimpiness with spiciness, I couldn’t handle it. Michael however, I think he would luuurve this.

    • Actually, pimento cheese isn’t remotely spicy! Pimentos aren’t spicy…more like finely chopped roasted red peppers. Kinda. But no spice! So you’d be fine :-) (I’m a spice lightweight, too!)

  4. Ok, I have never had pimento cheese. But if you make me some of these beautiful toasty sandwiches, I will gladly right that wrong!

    • If I wasn’t busy this weekend I would be showing up at your doorstep with the ingredients for this sammich and force-feed it to you. The baby would approve.

  5. You just did your Grandma mighty proud!! PS. Do you find it awkward writing directions for grilled cheese? I totally do. I digress. This looks epic!

    • YES! Omg, I’m so glad someone else thinks that. I really wanted to write, “Make the danged sandwich. If you haven’t figured out how to do that by now, you’re doomed.” Haha.

  6. I would like to have one of these right now. Talk about comfort food :)

  7. True story, I’ve never tried pimiento cheese before. Gasp! I KNOW. I need to change that immediately though because holy crap, I need that melty cheese sandwich in my life.

    • Well. You are a born and bred Yankee, so it isn’t really your fault that you weren’t raised right. ;-) But really…this is such a Steph food. You neeeeed to try this.

  8. You make my heart swell…Let’s do this and a bowl of tomato soup for dipping…that’s it. I’ve got every meal planned from here on out. Grilled cheese and soup. done and done. I’ve never actually purchased a jar of pimentos. It is time, my friend…it is time. :)

  9. This. I must have this. Be still my ever lovin’ grilled cheese heart.

  10. I love pimento cheese on crackers, but have never tried it this way! Looks amaaaazing!

  11. Mmmm I love a good grilled cheese. I have never had pimento cheese, but I have seen that stuff in a jar. I thought that’s what it was! And that’s why I was really kind of confused at the end of the Food Network Star finale lol. Thanks for showing me the light. Looks amazing!

  12. Just mouthwatering…looks delicious!


  1. […] Greek Yogurt Dip from La Terra Fina. I have a feeling that my future dipping needs will include homemade pimento cheese. I will warn you, however, not to think too much about your dipping needs, as this turns into a […]

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: